* This is a PDF document


OSSA-Second Conference
PAPERS AND PRESENTERS



Keynote Speakers
  1. Billig, Michael (University of Loughborough) "Rhetoric and the Unconscious"ABSTRACT
  2. Jackson, Sally (University of Arizona) "Disputation by Design"ABSTRACT
  3. Rescher, Nicholas (University of Pittsburgh) "The role of rhetoric in argumentation" ABSTRACT
Papers
  1. Aberdein, Andrew (Logic and Metaphysics, St. Andrews)"Persuasive Definition"
    (Commentator: Bruce Russell, Philosophy, Wayne State)ABSTRACT
  2. Adler, Jonathan (Philosophy, Brooklyn College & the Graduate Center CUNY)"Arguing from Ignorance"
    (Commentator: Dale Jacquette, Philosophy, Penn State)ABSTRACT
  3. Allen, Derek (Philosophy, Toronto) "Should We Assess the Basic Premises of an Argument for Truth or Acceptability?"
    (Commentator: Ralph Johnson, Philosophy, Windsor)ABSTRACT
  4. Bailenson, Jeremy, & Lance J. Rips (Psychology, Northwestern) "Claim Strength and Burden of Proof"
    (Commentator: Stuart M. Keeley, Psychology, Bowling GreenABSTRACT
  5. Blair, J. Anthony (Philosophy, Windsor) "The Limits of the Dialogue Model of Argument"
    (Commentator: E.C.W. Krabbe, Philosophy, Groningen)ABSTRACT
  6. Boger, George (Philosophy, Canisius) "Aristotle's Treatment of Fallacious Reasoning in Sophistical Refutations and Prior Analytics"
    (Commentator: David Hitchcock, Philosophy, McMaster)ABSTRACT
  7. Bradshaw, Leah (Politics, Brock) "Emotion, Reason and Judgment"
    (Commentator: Connie Missimer)ABSTRACT
  8. Browne, M. Neil (Economics, Bowling Green), Terri J. Keeley (Virginia), and W. J. Hiers (Cornell) "The Rhetorical Burden of Expert Witnesses"
    (Commentator: Derek Allen, Philosophy, Toronto)ABSTRACT
  9. Browne, M. Neil (Economics, Bowling Green) and R. G. Hausmann (Honours Program, Bowling Green) "Argument as an Act of Friendship"
    (Commentator: Herbert Simons, Speech Communication, Temple)ABSTRACT
  10. Cecchetto, Vikki and Inga Dolinina (Modern Languages, McMaster) "Facework and Rhetorical Strategies in Intercultural Argumentative Discourse"
    (Commentator: Charles A. Willard, Communication, Louisville)ABSTRACT
  11. Clauss, Patrick (English, Ball State) "Ethics on the Internet?: Usenet Newsgroups and the Subversion of Rationality"
    (Commentator: Jim Gough, Red Deer)ABSTRACT
  12. Cohen, Dan (Philosophy, Colby) "The Argument Against Rhetoric"
    (Commentator: Michael Leff, Communication Studies, Northwestern)ABSTRACT
  13. Dzialo, Michael G. (English, Yale) "Legal and Philosophical Fictions: At the Line Where the Two Become One"
    (Commentator: Christopher Tindale, Philosophy, Trent)ABSTRACT
  14. Edwards, James G. (Philosophy, Indiana) "Pathological Circularity: Deductive Validity and a Contextual Account of the Fallacy of Begging the Question"
    (Commentator: Lawrence H. Powers, Philosophy, Wayne State)ABSTRACT
  15. El Komos, Maged (Academic Skills & Cultural Studies, Trent) "Perelman as Educational Facilitator: the Realm of Rhetoric and the Acquisition of Rational Discourse"
    (Commentator: Claude Gratton, Philosophy, Sudbury)ABSTRACT
  16. Feteris, Eveline T. (Speech Communication, Amsterdam) "The Soundness of Pragmatic Argumentation: Does the End Justify the Means"
    (Commentator: Leo Groarke, Philosophy, Wilfrid Laurier)ABSTRACT
  17. Fisher, Linda (Philosophy, Windsor) "Is Reasoning Gendered?"
    (Commentator: Jacqueline Davies, Philosophy, Queen's)ABSTRACT
  18. Fleming, David (English, New Mexico State) "Housing Rhetoric: Argumentation and City Planning"
    (Commentator: Ernest Sternberg, Architecture, SUNY at Buffalo)ABSTRACT
  19. Freeman, James B. (Philosophy, Hunter College, CUNY) "What Types of Statements are There? A Philosophical Look at Stasis Theory"
    (Commentator: Marie Secor, English, Penn State)ABSTRACT
  20. Gilbert, Michael A. (Philosophy, York) "Prolegomenon to a Pragmatics of Emotion"
    (Commentator: Charles A. Willar, Communication, Louisville)ABSTRACT
  21. Girle, Rod (Philosophy, Auckland) "Belief Sets and Commitment Stores"
    (Commentator: John Woods, Philosophy, Lethbridge)ABSTRACT
  22. Goodwin, Jean (Communication Studies, Northwestern) "Forms of Authority and the Real Argumentum ad Verecundiam"
    (Commentator: Hans Hohmann, Communication Studies, San Jose State)ABSTRACT
  23. Gordon, Jill (Philosophy, Colby) "Why Didn't Plato Just Write Arguments? The Role of Image-Making in the Dialogues"
    (Commentator: Robert J. Yanal, Philosophy, Wayne State)ABSTRACT
  24. Gorman, Matthew (Philosophy, Toronto) "Preliminary Conditions for Rational Discussion, as Found in Plato's Gorgias"
    (Commentator: Carol Poster, English, Northern Iowa)ABSTRACT
  25. Govier, Trudy, (Calgary, Alberta) "Arguing Forever? Or: Two Tiers of Argument Appraisal"
    (Commentator: Ralph H. Johnson, Philosophy, Windsor)ABSTRACT
  26. Gratton, Claude (Philosophy, Sudbury) "Infinite Regress of Recurring Questions and Answers"
    (Commentator: Joseph A. Novak, Philosophy, Waterloo)ABSTRACT
  27. Halsall, Albert W. (French/Carleton Centre for Rhetorical Studies, Carleton) "The Topics in Classical and Modern Theories of Interpretation"
    (Commentator: Hans Hohmann, Communication Studies, San Jose State)ABSTRACT
  28. Hayes, Calvin (History, Brock) "Critical Rationalism and Pragma-Dialectis: A Marriage Made in (Logicians') Heaven?"
    (Commentator: Francisca Snoeck Henkemans, Speech Communication, Amsterdam)ABSTRACT
  29. Hicks, Darrin (Human Communication, Denver) "Subjectivity and Governance in Procedural Theories of Argument"
    (Commentator: Eveline Feteris, Speech Communication, Amsterdam)ABSTRACT
  30. Hitchcock, David (Philosophy, McMaster) "Enumerative Induction"
    (Commentator: Rod Girle, Philosophy, Auckland)ABSTRACT
  31. Hughes, William (Philosophy, Guelph) "Why Ethics Should be on the Critical Thinking Syllabus"
    (Commentator: William Abbott, Philosophy, Waterloo)ABSTRACT
  32. Jacquette, Dale (Philosophy, Penn State) "On the Relation of Informal to Formal Logic"
    (Commentator: Hans V. Hansen, Liberal Studies, Brock)ABSTRACT
  33. Johnson, Ralph (Philosophy, Windsor) "Differences Between Argumentative and Rhetorical Space"
    (Commentator: Joseph Wenzel, Communication, Illinois Urbana-Champaign)ABSTRACT
  34. Kauffeld, Fred (Edgewood) "Presumption and the Distribution of Argumentative Burdens in Acts of Proposing and Accusing"
    (Commentator: James B. Freeman, Philosophy, Hunter - CUNY)ABSTRACT
  35. Kloosterhuis, Harm (Law, Erasmus) "Analogy Argumentation in Judicial Decisions: A Speech Act Perspective"
    (Commentator: Jerome Bickenbach, Philosophy, Queen's)ABSTRACT
  36. Kominar, Robert A. (Law and Justice, Laurentian) "Rhetoric vs. Argument: Searching for a Paradigm in ADR"
    (Commentator: Jerome Bickenbach, Philosophy, Queen's)ABSTRACT
  37. Krabbe, Erik C. W. (Philosophy, Groningen) "Who is Afraid of a Figure of Speech?"
    (Commentator: John Hoaglund, Philosophy, Christopher Newport)ABSTRACT
  38. Makus, Ingrid (Politics, Brock) "Feminist Reasoning About Reason"
    (Commentator: Carmel M. Forde, Philosophy, Dalhousie)ABSTRACT
  39. Mathewson, Gwen C. (English, Washington) "Outdoing Lewis Carrol"
    (Commentator: Jacqueline Davies, Philosophy, Queen's)ABSTRACT
  40. Mathie, William (Politics, Brock) "Thomas Hobbes on Political Science and Rhetoric"
    (Commentator: Philippe Azzie, Political Science, Carleton)ABSTRACT
  41. Missimer, Connie (Seattle, WA) "The Intuitive Fallacy, Continued"
    (Commentator: Christina Slade, Communication, Canberra and New York)ABSTRACT
  42. Palmer, Terri (English, Carnegie Mellon) "The Dictates of Reason: Bacon, Ramus, and the Naturalization of Invention"
    (Commentator: Corrado Federici, French, Italian & Spanish, Brock)ABSTRACT
  43. Pinto, Robert C. (Philosophy, Windsor) "Coherence, Logic and Psychology"
    (Commentator: Jonathan Adler, Philosophy, Brooklyn College and Graduate Center, CUNY)ABSTRACT
  44. Plug, Jose (Law, Erasmus) "Indicators of Additional Considerations in Judicial Decisions"
    (Commentator: David Godden, Philosophy, York)ABSTRACT
  45. Powers, Lawrence H. (Philosophy, Wayne State) "Ad Hominem Arguments"
    (Commentator: John Woods, Philosophy, Lethbridge)ABSTRACT
  46. Reed, Chris (Computer Science, U.C. London) "Persuasion Monologue"
    (Commentator: Mark Vorobej, Philosophy, McMaster)ABSTRACT
  47. Rehg, William (Philosophy, Saint Louis) "Argumentation Theory and the Recent Philosophy of Science"
    (Commentator: Marcello Guarini, Philosophy, Western Ontario)ABSTRACT
  48. Ruhl, Marco (Philosophy, Freiberg) "Argument and Authority: On the Pragmatic Basis of Accepting an Appeal to Authority as Rational"
    (Commentator: Jean Goodwin, Communication, Northwestern)ABSTRACT
  49. Russell, Bruce (Philosophy, Wayne State) "Good Arguments and Fallacies"
    (Commentator: Richard Feldman, Philosophy, Rochester)ABSTRACT
  50. Secor, Marie J. (English, Pennsylvania State) "Mill's Fallacies: Theory and Practice"
    (Commentator: Raymie McKerrow, Interpersonal Communication, Ohio)ABSTRACT
  51. Slade, Christina (Communication, Canberra) "From a Critical Point of View: News as Soap Opera"
    (Commentator: Deborah Berrill, Trent-Queen's Concurrent Teacher Education)ABSTRACT
  52. Snoeck-Henkemans, A. Francesca (Speech Communication, Amsterdam) "The Pragma-Dialectical Approach to Argument Indicators"
    (Commentator: J. Anthony Blair, Philosophy, Windsor)ABSTRACT
  53. Souder, Lawrence G. (Speech Communication, Temple) "A Way to Describe and Evaluate Thought Experiments, or Trying to Get a Grip on Virtual Reality"
    (Commentator: Daniel H. Cohen, Philosophy, Colby)ABSTRACT
  54. Thomson, Christopher (Philosophy, Toronto) "On 'Burdens' of Proof in Ordinary Language Argumentation"
    (Commentator: Fred Kauffeld, Edgewood)ABSTRACT
  55. Vorobej, Mark (Philosophy, McMaster) "Fallacies on Film"
    (Commentator: David Birdsell, School of Public Affairs, Baruch)ABSTRACT
  56. Woods, John (Philosophy, Lethbridge) "The Normative Impotence of Ideal Models"
    (Commentator: Robert C. Pinto, Philosophy, Windsor)ABSTRACT
  57. Yanal, Robert J. (Philosophy, Wayne State) "Argument and Conviction"
    (Commentator: Robert W. Binkley, Philosophy, Western Ontario)ABSTRACT


    go back to OSSA1997 page